Is there a future for trusts after CRS?
The idea of setting up a trust, and thereby handing responsibility for your money and/or assets to a third-party trustee, is relatively commonplace across many jurisdictions and has been in place for centuries. Interestingly, the trend has only caught on in Asia in the past few decades, as the number of wealthy people who might make use of a trust has seen a dramatic increase. The reasons for setting up a trust are varied but there is an ever-growing need for maintaining confidentiality and protecting wealth for future generations, with an emphasis on tax-efficient planning. Setting up a trust can achieve these aims, and that is why it is becoming popular for Asians.
Recently, there has been a growing concern about whether trusts will continue to be fit for purpose in light of the introduction of tax transparency and reporting measures, particularly CRS. Since 2014/2015, many clients have been asking what the impact of CRS is likely to be on their trusts and offshore assets. Some are wondering if they still need a trust, as their assets would no longer be private. Others, arguably in a knee-jerk reaction, have terminated their trusts completely.
Now, with the impact of CRS settling in, the question is, will trusts still be relevant?
While CRS does take away a degree of privacy, it does not eliminate many of the other benefits associated with establishing a trust. To better understand the relevance of a trust as part of wealth planning, it is important to look at the most significant needs of trusts’ primary market, the high-net-worth individual (HNWI).
HNWI financial wealth is growing at a steady rate in Asia: 4.8 per cent from 2017-2018, according to Capgemini. HNWIs are a discerning market, with varied needs. They often hold a diverse range of assets comprising, for example, real estate (both long-term investment and development projects globally), interests in start-up or well-established trading entities, artwork and antiquities, and digital currencies. When it comes to wealth planning, the fundamental pillars of asset protection, succession planning and confidentiality are of the highest importance to them, and that is why they seek to partner with a trusted advisor. By looking at these main drivers of wealth planning, we can determine whether the future of trusts is truly under threat.
The issue of confidentiality is always an important one, whether it is through regard for personal and family safety or to maintain privacy in the public eye. While CRS does require some information to be reported to the financial authorities, information disclosed is not made publicly available, and as such the confidentiality provided by a trust still meets these needs.
The importance of income protection and succession planning for future generations is still present with the introduction of CRS. The need to have a succession plan in place for HNWIs with international, and often complex, family structures cannot be overemphasised. Critically, many wealthy Asian families are still first-generation empire builders versus the ‘old money’ generations of Europe and the US. They have worked hard for what they have today while their children and grandchildren lead a relatively comfortable life. The second and third generations are often well-educated and some have settled in foreign countries. The need to ensure that their hard-earned wealth is preserved is important to these patriarchs and matriarchs and a trust continues to provide them with this security.
Certain benefits provided by a trust, such as creditor protection, are important to many when planning for their family. Unforeseen circumstances may present themselves to the family at some point in the future and proper planning can help mitigate any negative impact on their family fortune.
As tax obligations continue to evolve, a trust coupled with an insurance policy will be able to provide beneficiaries with immediate liquidity to pay for any inheritance tax or provide cash flow to the family as required.
In the context of CRS, a trust has the additional benefit of consolidating all assets under a single structure. This provides a strong level of consistency in the required reporting to relevant authorities.
According to Knight Frank’s Wealth Report 2019, the number of wealthy individuals is continuing to grow year-on-year, especially in Asia, where the UHNW population (taking into account those with net assets of USD30m+) is predicted to increase 23 per cent by 2023. With this kind of foresight, the need for some form of planning is becoming even more important, and trusts are still very much a significant part of that equation.
In a recent article by The Asset on Chinese HNWIs, it was recognised that market uncertainty, coupled with the increase in wealth, has raised awareness around the importance of preserving wealth and inheritance. This has led to many Chinese HNWIs, mainly the young entrepreneurs, setting up family trusts.
So to answer the question, ‘do trusts have a future in the 21st century?’, the answer is ‘most definitely!’
Written by Wendy Yeo TEP, Trust Director, Equiom Singapore
This article has been carefully prepared, but it has been written in general terms and should be seen as broad guidance only. The article cannot be relied upon to cover specific situations and you should not act, or refrain from acting, upon the information contained therein without obtaining specific professional advice. Please contact Equiom to discuss these matters in the context of your particular circumstance. Equiom Group, its partners, employees and agents do not accept or assume any liability or duty of care for any loss arising from any action taken or not taken by anyone in reliance on the information in this article or for any decision based on it.
For more information on the impact of CRS on trusts, contact Wendy Yeo [email protected] or visit https://www.equiomgroup.com/locations/asia/singapore
The content displayed here is subject to our disclaimer. Read more